Post by redonihunter in Generate project link without owner username and/or a way to post a game anonymously

Viewing post in Generate project link without owner username and/or a way to post a game anonymously

You are aware that Itch is a store front for people to publish and sell their games? Like, publicly.

It is not supposed to be a file exchange from one person to a single other person.

Just use one of the regular file hosters for that. They do not have this "uploader" information and are rather anonymous from perspective of the downloader.

Also, game urls on Itch are always connected to the account and profile that published the project.

Oh, and if this is about urls only and not about files and keys and such, just use an url shortener. At the latest when viewing the page, the gifted person would know who made the game. Or when starting the game.

Like Reply

Hekateras177 days ago

I am perfectly aware of what itch is used for, thank you. I am not asking for a file exchange from one person to one person. The game should be publicly viewable. I want the game I publish this way to be public to everyone.

> Oh, and if this is about urls only and not about files and keys and such, just use an url shortener. At the latest when viewing the page, the gifted person would know who made the game.

I don't think you read my post.

Like Reply

redonihunter176 days ago

I read your post. Several times. Including the title.

Generate project link without owner username

This can be achieved with a simple url shortener.

And if you just want to gift copies of a game, use an external file hoster or some other way to obfuscate the keys/games. I do not grasp why it has to be an anonymous Itch project page. You are already anonymous. I do not know who you are. You can always make a sockpuppet throwaway account to upload a project and be anonymous and change the name of the account later. But I would consider this abuse of the Itch facilities for a mere one time secret santa thing - which by the way is exactly one person to one person. It defeats the purpose to be a public page. Especially the gift part. That sounds like a key to a paid game.

So whatever this is supposed to be, it does not sound like a secret santa. If you have a broker that knows who is who, you can upload the projects on that broker account "anonymously".

Is this maybe some blind jam thing or similar?

Anyways, there are all sorts of problems. It would be much easier to organize the "secret santa" event on some other platform and have the projects on Itch regularly after the event.

Like Reply

Hekateras176 days ago (5 edits)

You yourself pointed out the problem with using the URL shortener when you suggested using the URL shortener and pointed out that the username is still visible in the final URL after the game loads. I don't want that. I would like a custom URL for the game page, a URL without the username. I realise now I was less than clear about that, but I also think I provided enough information for you to understand what I mean, and you dismissed that information because you don't understand why someone would want that.

I see from your questions that we're on completely different pages about the needs of this event. I'd just like to point out that I deliberately said "a Secret Santa-type thing" - it was meant to convey broad strokes, not imply every detail is the same. I'll explain more.

> Is this maybe some blind jam thing or similar?

I've done game jams but not blind game jams so maybe.

Imagine a game jam event where instead of making a game (just) for a theme, you specifically tried to make some other participant's dream game for that participant, and some other participant (whose identity you do not know) tried to make your dream game. You get (say) a month to do it, you post by the deadline and then the gifts are revealed. However, for the first week of the games being revealed, you don't know who made what. This serves several purposes: the mystery is fun (and the guessing game is fun, based on people's signature styles and little tells), and creator-blind enjoyment of the games helps form more objective opinions. While the game you made was for one specific person, you usually look at other people's gift games, too, because odds are high that other people made games you like even if they weren't made specifically for you. Then creator reveals happen and you go "Wow, my gift game was made by someone who's never made a platformer before, but it's so good!" or "I had no idea my gift game was made by a close friend". And then (optionally) you go and see what other things they made, if you really liked their work. That's why the work should both be public and (ideally) be on the same account as your other works.

The intent is not to distance oneself from one's work permanently and completely, it's only temporary. If I gift someone a game and they don't know it's me, but they open a page with the URL hekateras.itch.io/CoolGame then, well... takes some of the fun out of it. That's why I was thinking that a custom URL could be a workaround. If they load a game and the page URL is just itch.io/CoolGame, it's a lot less obvious. (There's also the "View All by [Username]", "Follow [Username]" overlays, which isn't ideal either, but asking for that to change would be more ambitious. I'd be fine with just a custom game URL.)

> Especially the gift part. That sounds like a key to a paid game.

As I hope I made clear now, it is a gift because the entire game itself was created as a gift. I do not have plans to monetise the game at any point.

> You can always make a sockpuppet throwaway account to upload a project and be anonymous and change the name of the account later.

That is my fallback options but has many downsides - for one thing, changing the account name will invalidate existing game links, right? Specifically because the account name is in the game URL. This is extremely undesirable. So even if I upload games to a sockpuppet account for this, I would still want a project URL that's not tied to the account name.

I do not think a custom webpage URL that doesn't have the creator in the URL itself would be "an abuse of itch.io's facilities".

> Anyways, there are all sorts of problems. It would be much easier to organize the "secret santa" event on some other platform and have the projects on Itch regularly after the event.

It is organised on some other platform. But that other platform does not allow html5 hosting, which is where itch comes in. I don't know where you got the impression that I was asking for all this to happen on itch; I was only providing context on why I wanted a game URL without the creator name in the first place. (Clearly unnecessary and counterproductive.)

Like Reply