Top ratednot in game jams tagged creepypasta Page 2 (126 results)
Explore games not in game jams tagged creepypasta on itch.io. Scary legends shared around the internet · Upload your games not in game jams to itch.io to have them show up here.
New itch.io is now on YouTube!
Subscribe for game recommendations, clips, and more
The "Baby Face" killer is wanted! Mason seeks fame by breaking into "Baby Face's" home.
Puzzle
August 4th, 1993, every television in the town of Garotsville turned to this:
Play in browser
find the fabled frozen tuna from the freezer section!!
Adventure
In this game, you as a person who wants to have dinner but is constantly being harassed by a mysterious creature...
Adventure
An extended version of a short Minecraft horror game based on Music Disc 11.
Adventure
A 90's horror inspired first-person game about working the midnight shift at a gas station.
Adventure
Explore the abandoned Funhouse and escape the evil grin of Laffing Larry!
Adventure
Play in browser
A PC enhancement fangame recreation of the urban legend and obscure Gameboy video game Misfortune.gb
Puzzle
You head to Callinghton Forest tasked to investigate sightings of an unknown creature and to find skulls
Adventure
Compiled zniw prototype from some garbage cd found at the burned down [REDACTED]
Action
Play in browser
Loading more games...