Judge feedback

Judge feedback is anonymous.

• Heya, Overall, some strong lighting in this scene and an interesting idea. There are a few issues here that bring down what could be a very strong portfolio piece: 1. Your rubble/ rocks are very lumpy and fairly high res (9,000 tris for a rock) for the detail they have. I'd revisit these assets and try rebuilding them 2. You have some texel density issues with the flooring / walls. The bricks seem good, but the blended in dirt appears very low res- I'd investigate this some more and look into implementing a better vertex blend (using a heightmap, so we can see buildup between the brickwork) 3. You have a lot of railing - and train tracks. These are ripe for using tiling textures, but it seems you have unique unwraps for this - and the quality suffers because of it. I'd highly recommend using a tiling material instead of trying to do a unique unwrap. 4. Some of the scaling seems off, or is very hard to visualize - the lights are very large and don't seem right - is this intentional? 5. I'd love to see some more attention to detail for the skate ramps - they seem very uniform and clean with graffiti slapped on. Perhaps you could spend some more time on adding some dirt / grit to this.