Judge feedback

Judge feedback is anonymous and shown in a random order.

• Ive given you fairly low ratings for some elements because you missed the brief a little. By using so many re-used assets I think you've gained a big advantage over people who spent the competition time from scratch. But you acknowledge that and kudos to you for that.

  Overall, I was interested in this as it has good elements, the modular nature and the feel of the scene are good. 

  I worry it's a bit bland in places, it feel like you're missing a colour mask or diffuse texture to add interest to the materials. Aso you've reused the same texture across the pieces yet the main centre piece's textures are stretched and distorted. which makes it feel wrong. These are easy fixes in my opinion

  The level design and the composition is good.  
  

• A great start considering the amount of time you had left. Lovely compositions of the shots, the shapes and materials are really well-defined, and the lighting really helps accentuate the center piece. 

  The only comments I would give is that the cloth texture feels a bit rushed, and is definitely not as well-defined as the metals. The metal material is really nice, but it's a bit overused and makes everything blend in with each other a bit too much (did you not use all the materials shown in your documentation?). Too bad you were too restrained by time, as this could definitely make an outstanding piece had there been more time spent on it.