New & popular free Puzzletagged supernatural (136 results)
Explore Puzzle games tagged supernatural on itch.io · Upload your games to itch.io to have them show up here.
New itch.io is now on YouTube!
Subscribe for game recommendations, clips, and more
Navigate a maze of strange corridors. Use your flashlight to solve puzzles and more
Adventure
Play in browser
a streamer searches for a missing person while being stalked by something terrifying
Survival
Explore the mansion, solve puzzles, and uncover the secrets hidden within. Prepare for unexpected encounters.
Action
Fummy's classic RPG Maker horror game remade in RPG in a Box!
Adventure
Hide from a vigilant UFO, find weapon components, and protect the farm from malevolent extraterrestrial threats.
Shooter
Traverse elemental kingdoms in this hermetic point & click adventure
Adventure
Play in browser
10-20 Minutes of Gameplay | Eliminate anomalies, complete the upload, and reveal the ending...
Puzzle
A dark fantasy bar-pothecary game where you serve supernatural customers.
Puzzle
Play in browser
Mix cocktails for monstrous clientelle at a jazz bar in Hell
Simulation
Play in browser
Flee the evil that lurks in the dark in a short puzzle adventure game
Puzzle
Play in browser
Process anomalies for the Company Catalog and protect the world from the paranatural.
Puzzle
Play in browser
Perform rituals and slay demons using an unwieldy, oversized knife.
Puzzle
Play in browser
An isolated trailer park is choked by a strange occult rot. Short "cosmic horror" mystery game
Puzzle
Navigate the treacherous Ileban Point Lighthouse to reignite the beacon before the lake claims your soul.
Survival
All who enter this tomb will suffer the wrath of King Juniper...
Puzzle
Play in browser
Loading more games...