Since we didn't have a best overall game award, I took things into my own hands and made a little Google sheet with the individual scores of each game and the total number of points they earned. The 1st, 2nd, and 3rd highest scoring games in each category are colored as such. Right-click a column and select Sort sheet Z to A to see the ranking for each category!

Harold Jam 3 Overall Scores 

TL;DR

1. Re:PUNCH!!!
2. Harold: Show-Stopping Hero
3. Magical Girl Marsha