(Review originally written for MAY WOLF 2024)
The art is charming and has all kinds of nice extra touches that help the game establish its style & mood – there's a sense of steady directorial touch. Similarly, the comedy is hilarious, even if the whole doesn't feel perfectly balanced between humor and drama. Despite being overall pretty light in tone, low in conflict, and transparently horny, Burning Woof isn't really structured around its excellent gags or sex per se; the slightly less compelling character drama and slice-of-lifey exploration of the setting are what pushes it forward.
In that way, it kind of feels like a game not playing to its strengths. I was interested in the premise, but while the comparison between Burning Man and furcons is a fascinating idea, it was conveyed almost entirely via the author's note at the end – the way the work itself talks about the event feels plainly documentaristic, with not much deeper insight or satiric edge to it. The whole thing is basically taken at face value, and I guess I was just expecting some kind of novel angle, since the setting is such a narrative centerpiece even the interpersonal conflict can be seen as an extension of it?
Also, when it comes to the prose: grammar, punctuation, and vocabulary are often rough in a way that feels hard to ignore. There's a strong voice, but in my opinion, being more thoroughly edited would only help bring it out. Most of all, the linguistic quirks bleed into each character's dialog in a way I think doesn't feel entirely purposeful and makes them not as distinct as they could be. The VN is not unreadable or anything, and there are plenty of neat descriptions and fun lines, but the writing could be sharper.
Honestly, I'm not trying to be a hater here; Burning Woof was a breezy, engaging read with a clear vision. There's just a lot about the execution and what the story ultimately accomplishes that gives me a slight pause.
I can't believe I forgot to rate peak..... anyways love you vantaa. I too am just happy to be included in things
Im enjoying it so far!
Burning Woof is wacky and weird, but finds in idiosyncrasies an endearing quality that grips readers through a cute and personal story.
Primarily a comedy, this work presents with a level of silliness that's hard to dislike. Meta jokes, comical mishaps and slapstick are presented alongside interpersonal conflicts without ever losing sight of the game's brand of levity. This makes for an experience that's upbeat but neither overbearing or inconsistent.
The artstyle comes with its share of oddities, but it becomes easily to abstract those when progressing through the game. Exaggeration is used to enhance comedy and is a good match to the wackiness on display here.
All in all, this is a light experience that knows its identity well and makes good use of limited scope and resources. Burning Woof is funny while still reaching more personal and even touching notes.
Definitely recommending ChoPro fans to read this one! Very cute story with a few references you may recognize 😌
A promising start with quite a bit of intrigue. I like how the game knows when to take itself seriously and when to joke around. There's some top-notch character work here. The flashbacks started to feel intrusive after a while, but it never got bad enough that they detracted from the experience. Overall, a great beginning to a story.