Maybe I've done something wrong. I can't see my game in the submit dropdown to select it. I could have used the wrong options or something on my game's page. I can see older games I've created in the drop down and I made sure my single-page pdf game is public and shows up on my profile page. Has anybody else run into this? Is there some gotcha about submitting a game that is marked as a "physical game"?

OMG nevermind. I figured it out. It was submitted, that is why it wasn't showing up. I think this is the first time I've entered a jam by first using the "upload your game button" on the jam page and I didn't know it was submitted after I got done with all the other parts of setting up my itch game's page. :P