Skip to main content

On Sale: GamesAssetsToolsTabletopComics
Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Filter Results

(Clear)
Tags

Mystery

Weaving intrigue and suspense, these experiences challenge players to uncover hidden truths, solve puzzles, and piece together clues in enigmatic narratives or atmospheric settings.

Suggest updated description

Top$15 or less tagged Mystery and supernatural (25 results)

Explore physical games tagged Mystery and supernatural on itch.io · Sell your physical games on itch.io to have them show up here.

New itch.io is now on YouTube!

Subscribe for game recommendations, clips, and more

Monster of the Week haunted house mystery
A 3rd party supplement for the Triangle Agency TTRPG.
A time loop horror TTRPG for one or more players
6 Missions for the External Containment Bureau RPG
A trpg about helping passengers get to where they gotta go.
RPG of Covert Magickal Intelligence. Primal & malevolent forces work against the ascendancy of Elizabethan power.
Improvise supernatural mysteries in the style of Gravity Falls
A modern-day paranormal investigation game
Interdimensional Detectives fighting Time Crimes!
Conspiracies and Missions for the External Containment Bureau
4 Mysteries by GMs of popular MotW actual play podcasts
A supernatural apocalypse TTRPG
Studio MothmenVerified Account
A Tabletop Role-Playing Game
A simple TRPG about funny and mysterious tales.
A solo Carved from Brindlewood TTRPG of X-Files meets Fallout vibes
A fun-sized tabletop roleplaying game of sleuthing and ghosts
A potentially world-ending big bad Monster of the Week mystery!
System Neutral Supernatural Mystery
Play as a member of a team dedicated to tracking down and capturing various cryptids to be studied in secret.
For use with Monster of the Week by Michael Sands.
Matters concern Lost Books, Befouled Poppets, Paradoxical Poultry, and Assorted Hellscapes
A case file for Paranormal Society
A case file for Paranormal Society
itch.io now on YouTube!