Overall: Tight gameplay, simple mechanics that build in intensity, great graphics and sound; what's not to love?
Gameplay: Felt really good with the combination keyboard/mouse layout. Gameplay mechanics were easy to remember, but all the enemies turned it into a bullet hell near the end. Really great balance of convenience and challenge, a benchmark I think many other devs should strive to reach (myself included).
Music: Great selection of 8-bit tunes and I loved the Sawyer banger at the end.
Story: Not a lot. I also couldn't see how the game ended because Godot gave me a black screen after I beat the final boss. I could still hear everything that happened though.
Graphics: Sprites are really clean and have a lot of character despite their resolution. Loved the CGs during cutscenes as well. It should come as no surprise your art is among the best of the jam and very possibly my 5-star.
Comedy: Not a lot but that's not a big deal.