Overall a quite fun little game. The gameplay loop got repetetive about half way through and I felt it was too easy, but the idea of a Papa's type of game with potions is great, and with polish and simply more stuff the game could be really fun. Btw you should look into using assets with consistant pixel sizes, as that would probably make the game look better very easily.
Also for a jam game the story is basically shakespeare, and I saw the light.