Bahaha, well... Spencer is the default route, so if you ignore everyone else basically earn few to no points with them, it defaults to Spencer.
Viewing post in Extracurricular Activities comments
I think what it was, was I was hard skipping to choices so if I waited for it to skip manually it showed up. Also any word on why the scene with catching Spencer in the act during Richards route is no longer available? does it only unlock if you've completed Spencer's route, which my game has probably forgetten