I think my top 5 girls (Personality's or Appearances) would be:
1. Luna
2. Alex
3. Annie
4. Delilah
5. Nova/Penelope (Nova & Penelope are tied for 5th)
Shallow pervs overlook how Nancy is portrayed here relative to other games. Harem-wise, she already knows about Delilah, Penelope, and Annie, is invested herself, and has a pretty good idea about Luna. And she berates MC to go get Nova. That's a pride picking the mane, not the mane picking the pride. Nancy is in charge.