I've played ALL of the Midnight Scenes games so far... and this is actually my favorite and the most memorable in my opinion! I played the whole game here:
It was really awesome, and I personally find non-supernatural horror stories the scariest because they could actually happen! This is a totally plausible story and I really felt for Phil and Noelle during the whole thing. My full thoughts are in the video above but I'm always blown away by the quality of the games and can't wait for the next ones!!