I don't play on nightmare, I used them as examples for how quickly things scale beyond what is 'advertised'. Your assumption is weird considering I detailed what it was on normal then said 'imagine' what the differences are like in nightmare. Let me give you a reverse example, I was very lazily playing story mode at one time, exploring the opposite side of the balance. Obviously it is quite trivial thanks to 10x gold and workshops not elapsing time. So I was fighting a boss, underprepared compared to a higher difficulty, just using regular attacks to ease through it. They were only doing 1 damage after all. So a boss on story mode dealing 1 damage, you wouldn't think is about to kill me right? It winds up, sure, something to think about if I was playing seriously on a higher difficulty, but it was flashing yellow so I just decided to test out if I'd kill it. I didn't. So this story mode encounter that was dealing 1 damage, with its enhance and wind up uses pierce, one shotting me on story mode. *The point isn't whatever you think it is.* I'm using *examples* for how egregious many enemies multiply their damage and disregard your defense.
Frankly you were quite rude and misunderstood the broader points throughout (often even echoing my point that many allies exist just to guard as a damage sponge while ironically trying to disagree with me.)
> Charlotte is very squishy to physical attacks yeah. That's why protect exists.
Which I covered, didn't I? "You either have to JUST protect her" I was also referring to times where she isn't accompanied by John, where she doesn't have that protection outside of Aura or a slime, which just turns other characters in to protect-bots. Obviously heat up is good, I'm not an idiot. But again, if you don't ignore the broader point, her existence then makes John just a protect-bot. Notably you completely omitted a response to John and Paul's magic vulnerability you CAN'T effectively defend against, ESPECIALLY post-avaritia.
> The game can be a bit rng at times, but if you need more than a few tries against a boss due to rng, it's usually because you're not strong/skilled enough and are trying to brute force it (which is a valid tactic if and only if you think it is fun)
You are mistaken if you think that this isn't the case for me, but if you think it's good balance to still be susceptible to RNG even when you ARE strong enough, then we just disagree. No amount of real consistency can be achieved.
> He contributes 50 extra hp, which is actually quite a lot at that point in the game.
You know, except it's not because avaritia > dark attack > tactical crit generally one shots ANY ally through their guard, especially if they reach enhancement.
> step up your game to meet the bar.
Sure I'll just dodge the moves like I'm playing Elden Ring. Oh wait it's a turn based RPG where even the standard difficulties are quite grindy. There's no such thing as 'stepping up your game'. There's grinding for more stats (something that uses precious time) and relying on luck. Your tactical advantage dodges are luck. Flash bombs avoiding damage are luck. It's luck and grind all the way down, which contradict many of the timed events and rewards in the game.
> you come across more as a whiner
And yet I must be agreed with on some level because this post had likes, which are rare here, and the linked comment to the weekly release had at least 3 last I checked. Even one of the other threads posted today mentioned they play on story because of poor difficulty.
Getting personal with me over a game like this is some weird shit.