This is REALLY PROMISING, but I do have a list of issues I want addressed:
1. Height: You are incredibly short in this game, making it difficult to grab the cookies, brush, or most of anything in the game, it would be great to scale down the levels so you are taller within the areas.
2. Turning: 101% requires snap/smooth turning with the joystick, the geometry of the levels make it a real hassle for wired headsets
3. Jank: dropping the flashlight can make it clip through the floor, tattletail can just randomly start screaming in your hand because he thinks you dropped him, it would be nice if you had like a flashlight holster, you can run in place, and you are already planning on addressing save data issues.
This is currently all I have to say, please continue working on this, I can understand remaking a game completely from scratch is incredibly hard, I appreciate the effort. Will update this list if I find more.