Actually it happened THREE Times;
First there was Chip's Tips by TorpleDook for the Dread X Collection of Anthology Horror games
then prior to this; there was Flint's Hints a Psychological Horror game made in Godot Engine made by Scaredy Cat Studios
and Now There's a Mascot Horror game version of Blue's Clues by the same Developer of Imaginary Friend Asylum & The Friends we left behind Called Mint's Hints
BTW You'd have THREE nickels; NOT just 2; Because Blue's Clues being made into a horror game happened THRICE, not TWICE!!