*Spoiler (major)* this is just a theory but Orlando put sacrifice and saw you hanging from a meat hook and Dean said he feels that you will need to hurt yourself one day to do the right thing perhaps the MC came to the conclusion or was forced into a position where that someone had to die or they all would, thus the sacrifice being the MC for his friends lives that still wouldn't explain the meat hook since there are other ways to KYS so perhaps the white ghost has some thing to do with it? Or Dean means emotionally hurt not physically like letting the love interest go or die? dont know whats some other thoughts?
I hope your wrong or at less I hope we can somehow avoid it. I already had one disappointing ending to a VN I really liked with in the last few months where you have no way to save the person you date. I'm still upset about it and I really hope they go back and give us a good ending at some point I don't even want to read any of their other VN because of this I just don't trust them anymore XD. My theory is that the meat hooks are in the Cabin I bet it’s a hunting cabin and the meat hooks are used to hang the animal as you clean and cut them up.
I'll tell you this much. This VN does have a good end planned where everyone survives including a romantic end for your husbando if you've opted for romance instead of just friendship.
Cause otherwise... yeah, spending a whole game without a clear 'good' ending when you're strung along to believe there should be is rough.
well yeah I expected that since the point of this game is kinda experience the bad to learn more and get to the good I was just thinking that you are going to sacrifice something and through that sacrifice you learn the truth and the way to save everyone perhaps a password or something else. on a side note Deans starting to worry me a bit he has a lot of foreshadowing in his route and I kind of had an epiphany with his death it said he died because of poison or similar and it wasnt deathcap since it takes ~6 days to die (Mycology book) so what if he found something that hut that was mentioned or a lab, where there are poisons stored he touched something there and forgot to wash his hands but the question if this is true why didn't he tell anyone perhaps he didn't think it mattered? or another case is it didn't seem to have anything dangerous with a brief look, sorry for ranting writing helps sort my thoughts
No worries XD I actually have some suspicion for Dean myself. I think he may actually be the one killing people. Don't forget he did try to feed you with that unclean poison hand. Grizz did tell me there is a reason you are being pushed towards Dean. In Orlando's case I think Dean is trying to get Orlando to set you up with him. I think Dean is targetting the others because you are getting closer to them. Ty was killed by what looks like a wild bear Sal was receiving medicine from Dean. Dean is linked to at less one of these deaths and the other is a strange coincidence. I'm starting to think Dean maybe trying to Romeo and Juliet you. The night Dean died he may have intended for you both to die. I'm not saying Dean is behind it all. Its possible he thinks the only way to save the others is to kill you but he doesn't want to live without you so he intended for you both to die. I think as the story progresses we will need to stop all of them from killing each other. Maybe even your self at some point.
well its hard to say its one person since the way they were murdered would make you suspect themselves if that makes sense because hoss was murdered by someone who knew the secret passages or it wouldnt be possible and he had at least known one. Orlando was murdered by someone who knew the signifigance of the vault and knew the code to it while Orlando knows neither he is the closest to learning both. Ty was murdered by what seemed like a wild bear/animal and the one who acts the most like one is Ty (no offence I like Ty too). then Sal the poor boy felt immense guilt and Hypnos told him to atone when the only one who he told was you soo... you could also argue Dean since they said they know eachother from before too. while in Deans you were worried about a suicide no more proof then that cause I can't think of any as for Roswell I can't think of anything. after saying this if it's a known character I think it comes down 3 people Dean for the motive, Butler since he suits the bill for a suprising amount of the deaths (these being Roswell, Orlando, Dean and Hoss) and this the most out there one but I can't stop thinking about it you, specifically future you for sal you knew his guilt and nightime hypnotisation for Dean I have feeling we'll figure out were poison is stored soon for Hoss you are learning the hidden passages and future you would know more also you knew he would be knocked out at the time for Orlando butler said we will learn the code to the vault after the medallion chase so future you may know it for Roswell it's another case of hidden rooms since the room was locked in and for Ty I can't quite think of anything. But for the butler, future you knew where a gun was going to be future you may think someone has to die and decided on the poor butler or even thought the butler the killer and stopped him preemptively not sure but I think whitey only appears when butler is missing which is suspicious so it could be the butler so in the end future you may be the killer why I don't know how I don't know but you can see an alternate dimensions future I don't think this that far out there but still it could be
It's probably because these sorts of discussions happen all the time on the Discord server (well not all the time but often enough) that it's always interesting when I see a new take on the how people died and who's behind the murders.
Straight up? A couple of people have already solved some of the murders, but the problem is that despite solving them, it hasn't given them enough information to crack the 'why'.
What I can say is that come Day 10, you'll get some more insight into the details of the murders that have happened so far, so that might help frame your theories a little better.
My advice is to remember that despite Dave's interception of whatever incident caused the murder, or the circumstances leading up to it, other things are still moving unhindered in the background, sometimes regardless of route.