Same problem asking Scarlet softlocks Thea. Also, you cannot ask Scarlet for the second protection charm if you still have the option to ask her for the clothes. Is it still possible to ask Cynthia btw? Doesn't seem like it.
yeah no i had to go reload an old ass save and re-do stuf
Same
Also, is it just me or is a sex scene permantly visible in Cynthia's room? Really seems like a few bugs crept in since last I checked.