Your choice.
I completely understand your opinion, mostly the toxicity and the nsfw part. I just hope you'll be okay with the people in a new fandom, or possibly a fandom you're already in.
In my opinion, since tattletail is a pretty small fandom currently due to it being old, it's pretty chill and peaceful there. Although it might not have the BEST of characters, I still think the lore is pretty awesomesauce.