Well, after going through all 336 possible combinations, this is my list of potion recipes in Alpha 0.17.
They work the same between saves for me, so if they don't work for you then it's a per-computer thing.
Rather than sort by recipe as the person above did, I sorted by what it affects.
Body: Female -Violet,White,Cyan
Body: Futa -Violet,White,Orange
Body: Male -Violet,White,Red
Arms: Fiendish Arms -Black,Pink,White
Body Cover: Fur -Black,Pink,Red
Body Cover: Fur Moth -Black,Red,Green
Body Cover: Fur Spotty -Black,White,Cyan
Body Cover: Fur Wasp -Black,Violet,Cyan
Body Cover: Scales -Black,Orange,Cyan
Body Cover: Scaly Face -Black,Green,Orange
Body Hair: Hairy -Green,Pink,Violet
Body Hair: Heart Shave -Orange,Cyan,Red
Body Hair: Messy Strip -Orange,White,Pink
Body Hair: Shaved -Orange,White,Cyan
Body Hair: Small Strip -Orange,Cyan,Black
Body Hair: Strip Shave -Orange,Cyan,Green
Body Shape: Average -Violet,Red,Cyan
Body Shape: Built -Green,Orange,Black
Body Shape: Chubby -Violet,Red,White
Body Shape: Fit -Violet,White,Black
Body Shape: Muscular -Violet,White,Green
Body Shape: Petite -Green,Orange,Cyan
Body Shape: Shortstack -Green,Orange,White
Body Shape: Skinny -Violet,Red,Pink
Body Shape: Slender -Green,Orange,Red
Breasts: Bolt On Breasts -Green,Red,Black
Breasts: Flat Breasts -Violet,Red,Orange
Breasts: Huge Breasts -Violet,Orange,Cyan
Breasts: Large Breasts -Violet,Orange,Pink
Breasts: Medium Breasts -Violet,Red,Black
Breasts: Perky Breasts -Green,Red,Orange
Breasts: Saggy Breasts -Green,Orange,Pink
Breasts: Small Breasts -Violet,Red,Green
Brows: Cyclopean Brows -Black,Green,Pink
Brows: Fuzzy Brows -Orange,Red,Cyan
Brows: No Brows -Green,Black,Violet
Brows: Pretty Brows -Red,Black,Violet
Brows: Spot Brows -Black,Red,Orange
Butt: Average Butt -Orange,Green,White
Butt: Beefy Butt -Green,Violet,Cyan
Butt: Big Butt -Green,Violet,Pink
Butt: Bubble Butt -Violet,Orange,Black
Butt: Fit Butt -Green,White,Orange
Butt: Heart Butt -Violet,Green,Pink
Butt: Huge Butt -Green,White,Violet
Butt: Petite Butt -Orange,Violet,White
Butt: Round Butt -Green,White,Red
Butt: Wide Butt -Green,White,Black
Butt Quirk: Firm Buttcheeks -Green,Violet,White
Butt Quirk: Soft Buttcheeks -Green,Violet,Red
Ears: Cat Ears -Black,Cyan,Pink
Ears: Deer Ears -Black,White,Orange
Ears: Droopy Ears -Violet,Black,Pink
Ears: Human Ears -Violet,Green,Orange
Ears: Kobold Ears -Black,Cyan,Red
Ears: Pointy Ears -Violet,Green,Black
Ears: Rabbit Ears -Black,Cyan,Orange
Ears: Siren Ears -Black,Orange,Red
Ears: Wolf Ears -Black,Cyan,Violet
Eye Color: Black Eyes -Violet,Black,Cyan
Eye Color: Blue Eyes -Red,Pink,Violet
Eye Color: Brown Eyes -Violet,Black,Red
Eye Color: Copper Eyes -Red,Cyan,Pink
Eye Color: Gold Eyes -Violet,Black,Green
Eye Color: Green Eyes -Red,Pink,Cyan
Eye Color: Grey Eyes -Green,Pink,Orange
Eye Color: Light Blue Eyes -Red,Pink,Orange
Eye Color: Light Brown Eyes -Violet,Black,Orange
Eye Color: Light Green Eyes -Red,Pink,White
Eye Color: Purple Eyes -Red,Pink,Green
Eye Color: Red Eyes -Red,Pink,Black
Eye Color: Silver Eyes -Violet,Black,White
Eye Color: White Eyes -Black,Green,Cyan
Eyes: Arachna Eyes -Green,Black,White
Eyes: Beady Eyes -Orange,Red,Violet
Eyes: Cyclopean Eyes -Black,Orange,Green
Eyes: Dopey Eyes -Orange,Red,White
Eyes: Insectoid Eyes -Black,Red,White
Eyes: Pretty Eyes -Red,Black,Orange
Eyes: Sharp Eyes -Orange,Red,Green
Eyes: Sly Eyes -Orange,Red,Black
Face Shape: Chubby Face -Green,Cyan,Violet
Face Shape: Gaunt Face -Green,Cyan,Orange
Face Shape: Normal Face -Green,Cyan,Black
Face Shape: Round Face -Green,Cyan,Red
Face Shape: Square Face -Green,Cyan,White
Face Style: Cheek Scars -Red,Black,Cyan
Face Style: Eye Scars -Red,Black,White
Face Style: Face Paint 1 -Red,Green,Cyan
Face Style: Face Paint 2 -Red,Green,White
Face Style: Face Paint 3 -Red,Green,Violet
Face Style: Face Paint 4 -Red,Orange,Black
Face Style: Face Paint 5 -Red,Green,Pink
Face Style: Freckles A -Red,Orange,Green
Face Style: Moles A -Red,Green,Orange
Face Style: Moles B -Red,Green,Black
Face Style: Moles C -Red,Black,Pink
Hair Color: Auburn Hair -Red,Cyan,Green
Hair Color: Blonde Hair -Red,Cyan,Orange
Hair Color: Brown Hair -Red,White,Pink
Hair Color: Coral Hair -Green,Red,White
Hair Color: Cyan Hair -Green,Red,Pink
Hair Color: Dark Blue Hair -Red,White,Violet
Hair Color: Dark Hair -Red,Cyan,White
Hair Color: Light Brown Hair -Red,White,Cyan
Hair Color: Light Green Hair -Green,Red,Cyan
Hair Color: Pink Hair -Green,Violet,Black
Hair Color: Red Hair -Red,Cyan,Black
Hair Color: Silver Hair -Red,Cyan,Violet
Hair Color: Violet Hair -Green,Red,Violet
Hair Color: Yellow Hair -Black,Red,Cyan
Hairstyle: Bun and Bangs -Orange,Cyan,White
Hairstyle: Buzzcut -Orange,Green,Black
Hairstyle: Double Bun -Orange,Cyan,Violet
Hairstyle: Long Hair -Black,Green,Violet
Hairstyle: Long Hair and Bangs -Black,Green,Red
Hairstyle: Long Ponytail -Orange,Pink,White
Hairstyle: Medium Bob -Orange,Pink,Cyan
Hairstyle: Mush Bob -Orange,Pink,Green
Hairstyle: Short Bob -Orange,Pink,Black
Hairstyle: Short Ponytail -Orange,Pink,Violet
Hairstyle: Sideswept -Orange,Cyan,Pink
Hairstyle: Sideswept Ponytail -Orange,Pink,Red
Hairstyle: Slickback -Orange,Green,Violet
Hairstyle: Undercut -Orange,Green,Red
Horns: Deer Antlers -Black,White,Red
Horns: Fiend Horns -Orange,White,Violet
Horns: Hobgoblin Horns -Orange,Black,Pink
Horns: Imp Horns -Green,Violet,Orange
Horns: Kobold Horns -Black,Violet,White
Horns: Moth Antennae -Black,Violet,Orange
Horns: Wasp Antennae -Black,Violet,Red
Mouth: Canine Mouth -Green,Black,Pink
Mouth: Fangs -Orange,Green,Pink
Mouth: Feline Mouth -Green,Black,Cyan
Mouth: Kobold Mouth -Black,Violet,Pink
Mouth: Pretty Mouth -Red,Black,Green
Mouth: Rodent Mouth -Black,White,Violet
Mouth: Ruminant Mouth -Black,White,Green
Mouth: Underbite -Orange,Green,Cyan
Mouth: Zombie Mouth -Green,Cyan,Pink
Nipples: Large Nipples -Violet,Orange,Green
Nipples: Medium Nipples -Violet,Orange,Red
Nipples: Puffy Nipples -Orange,Violet,Black
Nipples: Small Nipples -Violet,Orange,White
Penis: Average Penis -Orange,Black,Green
Penis: Small Penis -Green,Pink,Cyan
Penis: Tiny Penis -Green,Pink,White
Quirk: Arachna Skin -Black,Pink,Cyan
Quirk: Broad Shoulders -Green,Orange,Violet
Quirk: Large Nose -Green,White,Cyan
Quirk: Moth Neck Fur -Black,Red,Violet
Quirk: Narrow Waist -Orange,Violet,Cyan
Quirk: Slime Skin -Black,Green,White
Quirk: Spider Arms -Black,Pink,Violet
Quirk: Tiny Nose -Green,White,Pink
Quirk: Wide Hips -Orange,Violet,Pink
Quirk: Zombified Skin -Green,Pink,Red
Sclera: Black Sclera -Orange,White,Black
Sclera: Black Void Sclera -Green,Black,Red
Sclera: Bloodshot Sclera -Green,Pink,Black
Sclera: White Sclera -Orange,White,Green
Skin: Bikini Tan -Orange,Violet,Green
Skin: Spotty Skin -Orange,Red,Pink
Skin: Swimsuit Tan -Orange,Violet,Red
Skin Color: Almond Skin -Red,Violet,Cyan
Skin Color: Ashen Skin -Red,White,Orange
Skin Color: Beastly White Skin -Black,Pink,Orange
Skin Color: Chocolate Skin -Red,Violet,White
Skin Color: Cinnamon Skin -Red,Orange,White
Skin Color: Copper Skin -Red,Orange,Violet
Skin Color: Crimson Skin -Red,Orange,Cyan
Skin Color: Dark Grey Skin -Green,Black,Orange
Skin Color: Deep Blue Skin -Red,Violet,Black
Skin Color: Deep Green Skin -Red,Violet,Orange
Skin Color: Fair Skin -Red,White,Black
Skin Color: Light Blue Skin -Red,Orange,Pink
Skin Color: Light Green Skin -Red,Violet,Green
Skin Color: Olive Skin -Red,Violet,Pink
Skin Color: Pale Skin -Red,White,Green
Tail: Cat Tail -Black,Pink,Green
Tail: Fiend Tail -Orange,White,Red
Tail: Moth Abdomen -Black,Orange,Pink
Tail: Reptile Tail -Black,Cyan,Green
Tail: Short Tail -Black,White,Pink
Tail: Siren Tail -Black,Orange,Violet
Tail: Wasp Abdomen -Black,Violet,Green
Tail: Wolf Tail -Black,Cyan,White
Vagina: Innie Vagina -Violet,Green,Cyan
Vagina: Normal Vagina -Violet,Green,Red
Vagina: Outie Vagina -Violet,Green,White
Voice: Deep Voice -Orange,Black,White
Voice: Deeper Voice -Orange,Black,Cyan
Voice: High Voice -Orange,Black,Red
Voice: Soft Voice -Orange,Black,Violet
Wings: Moth Wings -Black,Orange,White
Wings: Wasp Wings -Black,Red,Pink