I think all of it is fine. It's what makes such games charming - indie-game devs allow themselves making craziest shit without any censorship / norms. As long as you won't compare it to something or judge it like game has billions of budget - such games will addict no less than high-budget games. MC' personality is one of the best in VN industry probably. He looks handsome enough and act funny / serious. Meme references just make it better.
And girls are horny around him for reasons: 1) There literally no men around the villages for a long time; 2) Bro got his mysterious mother-blood full of pheromones, and goddesses' blessings just make it worse [better]; 3) Big dick; 4) It just a silly game with lots of handsome&hot anime girls in it.
Overall narrative in the game is very good. Game has the funniest dialogue and situations I ever read. Literally all characters are funny / attractive / with background. Story progression is unexpectedly good that makes you wonder what will happen with characters in the next update instead of just waiting for another H scene. Give this game a chance
i also thing mc looks handsome the plot is interesting and the female characters are charming, but it doesn't change my opinion about Ryoko stupidity and the fact its annoying that the girls barely know mc and are already throwing themselves at him, and i don't care about the reason, it's just kills fun for me if every character first have serious conversation with mc but in the next second thing about his dick and try to seduce him (or mc just having conversation about some shit and his dick just grow) >:( + I hate characters who act selflessly without knowing the situaction, yet declare their willingness to help and claim they don't want anything in return (for a long run its just a trash trait). Probably i give this game a chance but i don't have much fate