You should be able to clear the selected item by clicking on an empty part of the menu or screen. The cigar has a use... There are two items that when used the right way will unlock a small extra scene during the ritual.
you let Dave give the uncle read the diary with the steamy scene, and let the uncle show Dave the cigarette. Then there is an extra scene when they fuck inside the sigil
I just got the diary from the library and the uncle is saying to look out side so yeah I'm wondering how to even get to the ritual or the "steamy" scene
