try going at a different time of day
I have the same problem, been there in the morning, day, evening and night. Same option every time, aka "Leave"
what version are you on
Latest one at the time, in the end I didn't even have to talk to him, it progressed past it when I did other quest lines. Not sure if that's one of several resolutions or whatever.
yeah i dont even remember having to talk to him with anything to do with annie, but as long as it got past that point
