Having a runner with four different options like you did is an interesting take. However, the game does not clearly communicate which is correct as I failed multiple times testing out different options.
Y'know what? That's actually my bad. I looked at the tutorial again and it does explain. I was using the same type/color instead of the opposite one, and generally picking options randomly at first because I think I accidentally insta-skipped the tutorial the first time around. Whoops.