I have just gotten the game and it seems like it could be fun, but... the fishing really sucks. I have nerve damage to my left hand so doing the finger voodoo dance to catch a fish just doesnt work for me. And it just seems over the top to do all of that just to catch a fish, it is not in sync with the rest of how the game plays. From what I have seen of the game play so far it is very straight forward, no weird movements required.
I have other questions I will look for the appropriate places to post them.
Thanks :)