yes i had a problem with this too! i replayed season 1 for that reason and still couldn't figure it out. but i selected that i did spend the night with her tho lol i'm not gonna miss that out
Yeah I ended up saying that I didn't spend the night with him in the spirit of honesty lol, I figured since I can't seem to puzzle it out so I was like "oh well" and just went without. But I still am so curious to know about it because I wanna know what happens XD