Yeah that was intentional no matter what you choose jaylene can't bring herself to answer. the one that matters is the one where rose and xanthe are fighting, its best not to choose anything in this regard and just wait
I think maybe it might be bugged then? Whether or not I choose reason or instinct, Jaylene says the same thing and both answers take me to the bad ending, or maybe my files are messed up, ill try restarting the game just in case