That's so weird, I went back into the game to record my screen and show you but it worked this time around, instead it just didnt drain the rewind bar lol I definitely haven't done anything different between the two plays and I guessed that was exactly what I needed to do
Viewing post in Rate for Rate - I will give every game the time it deserves
I reloaded a third time and got a recording of some bugs such as the rewind mechanic moving my player causing the mouse to disconnect from the rewinding object, going through the object, infinite rewind etc
https://webmshare.com/yjDKW