You have to see Alon's appearance in "conversation about weapons" scene in any of your playthroughs. If you have seen it, in Alon's afternoon scene you should get a bonus dialogue option that would lead to what you seek ;)
We'll see more of Max at the baths and in his own afternoon hangout path so I hope you'll like it :)
(btw don't let Alon know you think he's "cute"! ;P)
(...I think so too, though)