Ok, for some reason paragraphs aren't working. Am I missing something? I definitely used them when I typed this up. I even went back and tried doing two or three lines between paragraphs, but still no luck.
Edit: In case anyone else ever runs into this issue, the problem is that it doesn't upload/edit correctly if you create a new post while javascript is blocked. So if using no-script or similar, whitelist itch.io first.