Alright till the end there, not a fan of being presented choices that have the same outcome.
SPOILERS BELOW
The thing is, those choices don't really have the same outcome at all. For example: if you are not involved in a romance with Amelia and instead went on a date with Tanesha, she will hesitate to protect you and her brother will literally slash your face open. In addition to this more minor outcome, there is a major outcome that is immediately present at the start of Chapter 5... and how you handle the situation with him impacts the story/the player-character immensely. Every single punch you throw, for example, sends your "morality" rating into a downward spiral.
I recommend reading the walkthrough to see how choices impact the story if you're unsure. Nearly every single choice in this game all the way down to the very first crucial choice matters... but the outcomes/consequences aren't always immediately apparent. It would actually be quite silly/nonsensical if the consequences of your choices always presented themselves right away.