On Sale: GamesAssetsToolsTabletopComics
Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
Tags
(+1)

If the developer took care of their tagging situation this should help:

I have created a filter based on what we know right now (assuming it was 3D because of the first person, it was free or pay-what-you-want, or otherwise it would be in your library), but it still spits out 255 results. If you happened to have played it on Mac 57 results or 50 results on Linux. Or 201 results on Windows.

Maybe have a look at the Tag Directory yourself and see what else seems fitting.

Unless somebody who played that game as well happens to see this thread, your best chance will be: Going though those 200-ish cover images and hope the one the developer chose was representative of their game…

Thank you very much, Wechenbetelly! I have looked through the list and cannot find it. Perhaps the developer took it down... But thank you nevertheless!

(+1)

It’s entirely possible that the developer had a different thought process about their tagging situation than me… :/

While I’ve noticed a handful games vanish from itch in my (limited) time, in most of these cases they were either in a prototype stage (pretty common) or legally dubious (thankfully less common). While I can’t be certain, the description you gave made it sound like a game with interesting mechanics - which tend to stick around. :)

I mean no disrespect towards your computer of choice when I say this, but the game being available on Mac will help you to narrow the number of results down in future searches.