With all-due respect, this seems immensely vulnerable to brigading. Imagine a marginalized creator (many of which have made their homes on Itch) getting their profile mass-flagged by the right in an attempt to ruin their credibility. Sure, this could be moderated, but I don't think Itch has the capacity to do that efficiently.
Viewing post in developer red flags/ game red flags
extremely simple: dev makes store page, dev sells game, dev deletes everything = red flag
dev makes store page, dev sells game, dev deletes all downloads, dev uploads nothing in a reasonable time ex. 5 days = red flag that can be removed by restoring downloads
dev makes store page selecting "comes with steam key option", steam store page with "upcoming" status linked, game released on steam, 2 weeks pass, no keys have been added to itch.io key dispenser for valid purchases = red flag that can be removed by adding the keys sold
all the variables already exist for the store to work such as sales tracking, whether the DL page exists, whether the DL page is empty, etc.