Alright, following my idiocy from before (AKA leaving a controller plugged into my PC), I finally managed to complete the game!
As I mentioned previously, the atmosphere is great, it's very reminiscent of Silent Hill (complete with creepy mannequins that are like echoes of Silent Hill 2's glitchy weirdoes). The story is also great, and the voice acting throughout really adds to it. There are some pieces that you have to put together yourself as the player, which I love to see in games in this.
All in all a fantastic second entry to the Real Stories from the Grave series, although I was a bit taken aback by the end sequence with the stealth combat. It wasn't a bad element though by any means!
Well worth playing for anyone who likes a bit of narrative storytelling, exploring and surviving in the dark!