On Sale: GamesAssetsToolsTabletopComics
Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
Tags
(+1)

Oh boy oh boy...

After reading your description and the others comments I thought: "Someone put some efforts but made a kinda difficult game at the beginning with an ending that no one has seen??? Not on my watch!"

I tried and tried and tried. I made a map of your maze, I put the location of the houses. I made a map of the forest, and put the houses. I did not make a map of the third location, I think I have the gist of how it looks, and know where the houses are.

But I am stuck. Third house you can't enter, third location. There is a bird outside that follows me. Is it the end? Do I have to go somewhere else? If you tell me I might try one last time... to see the end.


But until now, what I can review is:

- The art is good! The pencil effect, the persistence of the image and the animation put us in the mood you clearly want us to have.

- The birds are scary at first (and still a bit in the end). But mostly annoying. And that is also intended. However, sometimes they show inside houses and make you move also, which might not be intended.

- The house should not spawn one after another. That is something bad. You lost your way, you wander around and finally find a house. Your first reflex is NOT to go back on your feet to check what you already checked.

- The audio hint is weird. It is there for the first two houses, disappeared until the third location...

- The camera.............. This. This is the real reason why everyone one drop the game before finishing it. I understand that the zoom in follows the overall logic. You are anxious around others, you like to stay safe, alone inside a house or something. Far from the crowed. And the zoom in symbolize the centering around yourself effect, wanting all the surrounding to just disappears and being alone again. But here you are, trying to find your way, trying to find a home, and you cannot see anything but big birds taking your whole screen and blocking your movements... I know it is a cool metaphor and might be an important element to the "story". But it is bad, really bad. I tried some many times because of this.


- A menu, a pause or a restart button? ;)

- Borders. Well, only the third locations don't have borders but it should have some. I wander in a random direction for a long time before going back and realize I had to follow the sound of houses... sound that was not here since the beginning !!!

- Is there something like all birds have different effects? And they are stronger together? That would be the only tiny link to the theme imo. You feel clearly stronger alone, and other birds are just annoying, being alone or together...


Well. It is a very interesting game. The mood is clear and you understand almost instinctively the story, because you live it. And it is not a happy one.

The level design is lacking. I find level design being something quite hard, and your game proves how important it is ;)


You have clearly done a lot of efforts to make that game, very good job. And I think you know what to work on to continue ;)

(+2)

Oh boy indeed! That's what I call serious approach)

Thank you for a great review, that's what I'm here for. You made me really happier today.

Also I feel ashamed, because yes, this is really the end and it doesn't deserve all of your efforts. I should have written "REALLY AWKWARD conclusion" in my description. It was done in the last hours of jam by a very sleepy me and the meaning was supposed to be like: it's the only silent bird in the game which is just following you not wanting anything. I always had the more meaningful one in my mind and it will be in the post jam version. And I'd be happy to see your maps))

I'm especially grateful for your criticism and already figuring out the solutions in the post jam version. Good point about spawning houses misleading players, didn't think about it, thank you! I definitely don't want them all to be in place from the start but the problem obviously will be solved this way or another.

You get most of my super-duper-obscure-subliminal messages so right! The idea with annoying birds and narrowing camera was like this: enemies should damage not the player in the game but the player in front of the computer. I guess I succeeded maybe a little too much. The problem is that the player doesn't have any tools to confront it and I definitely will try to fix it.

About fitting the theme. The original idea was to explore people's desire to get together all the time, the overrated significance of being social, to question the widely regarded benefits of communication with people. In many things we are stronger when we're alone. Probably it's not reading well, birds look like usual gamey enemies, chasing the player for no particular reason. It's one of the most important parts of the game, thank you for refreshing feedback.

And yeh, level design… I'm going to write a post about my experience during this jam and it's going to be an important point. It will be on gamin.me if anybody is interested, but it'll be in russian.

Sorry for lots of words, but I was really glad to talk to you. Post jam version will be largely redesigned and expanded, and I hope it'll be much better. Thanks to your feedback as well.

(+2)

I am glad my review was to your liking, I gained a shot on motivation and it ended up on your game haha

I think the fact that there was no hint that the game was finished was the missing stone. After knowing that it is the end, we can interpret the events in our own ways, maybe the one you thought about, maybe another. I would be glad to share my map but I am afraid it would spoil people who want to challenge themselves on your game ;) (I can show it to you by pm, what about discord? Shagar#2871)

For the theme part, your point is good, maybe like a "stronger together...?", I would have seen your message in a game where you need to find others to continue, as they are essential, but you also have the downsides and still need to be alone at some points... maybe.

Knowing your thoughts and confronting them to the feelings I had playing your games is very interesting, thank you for sharing all that !

You have great ideas I see, hope you will continue with them. ;)