This was great, I would absolutely love to see more of this. I honestly can't say what ending I prefer. The unsettling atmosphere and pay-off to the 'bad ending' was really good. If you've got the desire and the time I'd say you could make something great here whenever/if ever you decide to come back to it.
Heya, thank you so much! I'm really glad to hear people are still enjoying it this many years after its creation!
I'd definitely love to return to it, or at least to make something similar down the line, but it'd really depend on how much free time I had between my main projects, and if the artist responsible for the sprites/background, etc. would be happy to come back to work on it, as it requires working really closely with them for the best results.