Hey, I know you wanted to do a limited run at the $3.99, however people often don't scroll down to special rewards for a price reduction. It would be a really good idea to instead run it as a time limited sale using itch.io tools so people see up and front it is regularly $9.99 but for.. say 2 days it is $3.99
That way more people will click through, as itch market is very small for higher priced games.