Yeah, whether or not your game passes depends entirely on the person handling it. You don't get to appeal the ban either, as it's "not worth their time" to re-review a game and see if it meets their guidelines. The version of Imp you played here was the version that got me banned too, all because Sophie was flat chested for a single scene.
I've been thinking about opening a SubscribeStar. It would be nice to have a little extra income. I'll probably make an announcement once I make up my mind.