itch.io

Thank you for the kind comment! On the issue of the polarity of the answer and which aspect to focus on, I think they are both interesting. The way it's designed in the module, the focus is a little more on the situation where a character does something familiar but the prompt gets them to consider if they're doing it differently or for a different reason. The way you thought it should work is a little more focused on using whether or not they've done an action to draw attention to the fact that elements of their character may have changed. I think the way you propose might be a little more conducive for a "dramatic" style of play where characters change more across the course of play, while the way I originally designed it expects the characters to be somewhat stable and invites players to contemplate the nuances around subtle variations around a steady central theme. Honestly, before you asked the question I hadn't really considered doing things the way you propose, the way I originally came up with seemed to fit well enough to me that I didn't consider doing the opposite. I think the way I did it originally still makes more sense to me, but the way you thought it should work seems like it could be a cool and interesting variant.