yes, there should be 5 statues! The hint: it's in a very random place....
Did you spend the night at the inn as the final part of the Diplomacy quest? Did you check the Larklast markers and it's stated as having been completed already?
Ah, it looks like there was a glitch in between updates. Go to the shrine, and then Main Menu > Game Code and then "DaiCho" in the input. Check your devout list again - if you already have Alonra it should update your save file to show that you already have her!
Ahh, if you find the third statue (let me know if you need a hint) you'll be able to get fruit again. I'm gonna add in a patch to make it so you can still get fruit even if you don't find the statue soon!