i can't figure out how to get the worst one, but for the best: avoid anything that brings down your audience score, do anything that brings it up. here's what i ended up doing: 1. tell the full story. 2. try to climb the stairs. 3. avoid examining the teddy bear. open the evil book (by examining the bookshelf twice), then examine the wedding photo. 4. open the fridge. examine the postcards twice. 5. step in the summoning circle but don't light the candles 6. leave the house and speculate they sacrificed their daughter
i tried doing this and still didn't have enough audience score, so i'm just going to comment some additional things that I did:
- get mauled by the racoon. honestly didn't know this was going to happen so i don't know exactly what triggered the interaction. i had kinda low terror and it was the first action i did in the kitchen so it could be either of those
- open fridge in the kitchen.