Howdy haley,
Thanks so much for playing Up All Night, and for the kind comment! We're thrilled you enjoyed, and definitely recommend playing through the other endings when you get a chance. If you're interested, we also have an additional free one-shot which catches up with Nick years after the events, titled Up All Night: Rumination.
Thanks again! If you get around to it, we'd love to hear your thoughts on the other endings as well. :)