I guess it is a bit confusing.
But you need to progress all the leads to the end.
Like, the eldritch requires you to get help from the organisation and the fey.
The fey requires you to get help from chastity(eldritch) and the organisation.
You get it.
So you progress all of them until they all ask you to go to the same place.
Once you're there, click all the options at least once until the protagonist realises something is wrong and the leads change.