This is from a Day 3 bug with Haylee that I'm fairly certain is fixed on the Mega download/version of the game, though I could be misremembering slightly.
Essentially on the laptop, for day 3, after you get done talking to Ariel, Haylee comes online about 15 seconds later.
If you don't talk with her, the bug mistakes her for being online when she isn't. The fix to this, if it's not already fixed on the Mega version of the game, is to not try to message Haylee on day 5, as she isn't online that day anyway.
When you log off, it should be fixed for the next day.