Oh lord all the three routes/characters are adorable
In terms of pure looks, Leigh and Lucas aren't really my type but they're still pretty cute (but gawd Oscar is sexy, it's also the first time I've seen a buff/tall/muscular/hunk otter (aside maybe from Todd in TSR), they're usually portrayed as twinks in VN)
But personality wise, they're all loveable as heck
Still have a slight preference for Oscar and his flirty behaviour, too bad he's the only character we couldn't see blush in front of Wallace, I bet he would have looked hella cute
Lily is hilarious by the way, I noticed how female characters in gay furry VN are usually quite similar in a good way (quirky and funny characters that give big sis vibes, like Zoe in Psychic Connections and Ayako in Tennis Ace)
And I'm also completely hooked by the mystery surrounding this mysterious diary, can't wait to discover how it ended up like that