itch.io

Don't be too hard on yourself, I had a quick look to your game and it looks decent, with nice but simple animations and works fine. The only thing I would say is that with only a simple punch and a kick as the two only attacks, fights can become a bit slow. I'm no expert on this but I think the fun in this genre is to see the characters' different movesets (which usually take more than two buttons). You could try to give each plushy their own special moves, even if they only have two each, something wacky to catch the players' attention. But either way, I think you did a good job for this to be your first fighting game.