Enjoyment 4/5 - Very nice gameplay loop! Fishing is very fun, especially trying to nail the harder ones like the shark! Everything you want in a fishing game.
Concept 5/5 - Genius concept. A fishing game where you date what you pull up? I would love to see that expanded further.
Presentation/Execution 4/5 - I feel as though the concept could have been expanded just a bit more to really stick, maybe just a short dialogue with each date would have really sold it. But the actual fishing easily makes up for it.
Use of Limitation 3/5 - Limitation doesn't really tie into the game much, but it works fine and doesn't hold back the game.