I don't agree with the guy, but your reply was entirely off the mark and misrepresents his point to a degree that is more ridiculous than his opinion of the game.
You also accuse him of both "looking for a complete romance novel" and "just looking for Jerk of Material", which is entirely contradictory on top of being false.
Try not to overuse the "stupid cause horny" ad hominem, especially not in the comments for an adult novel, and even more so when you can't formulate a salient counterpoint yourself.