Yup I finally now found it! I tried again and got it immeditly ^^; What I did was change from picking Russel to then pick Chris and picking "I was a Chrisitan growing up" when talking to him I don't know if both of them made a difference. Sorry about that! ^^;
Looks like getting the sexual dream with Carlos only depends on whether or not you choose "I was a Christian growing up". I chose to side with Russel during the first FreshSem Lab as well as answering "I was a Chrisitan growing up" when talking to Carlos and still got it.
